Broker Check

Pension Plan Management

Municipal Pension Plan Management

Helping West Virginia Communities Take Care of the People Who Take Care of Them

The people who work for our municipalities, whether they're patrolling our streets, fighting fires, or keeping our communities running day to day, spend their careers showing up for others. The pension plan that supports them in retirement should do the same.

At Good Life Financial Advisors of West Virginia, JR Frenzel works directly with municipal pension boards across the state to simplify plan structure, reduce unnecessary costs, and make sure every board member walks into every meeting knowing exactly where the plan stands and why. This work isn't just another service we offer. For JR, it's personal.

Related Reading: Why Serving Police Officers and Firefighters Is PersonalWhy Serving Police Officers and Firefighters Is Personal

Public pension plans today face real challenges. Longer life expectancies, rising retiree-to-worker ratios, and inconsistent funding practices have put pressure on plans across West Virginia and the country. At the same time, investment returns, typically the largest source of pension funding, can lag when fees are too high, strategy is too complicated, or nobody is paying close enough attention. For the board members responsible for these plans, that's a lot to manage alongside everything else on their plates.

That's where we come in.

5 Keys to a Strong Municipal Pension Plan

Most pension plans don't struggle because of markets. They struggle because of cost structure, complexity, and a lack of consistent oversight. Here's how we think about it:

1. Cost Control Drives Long-Term Results
Gross returns get attention at board meetings. Net returns are what actually matter. Fees are one of the few things a plan can genuinely control, and every dollar saved in fees stays in the plan working for the employees who earned it. What looks like a small difference today becomes a meaningful gap over a 20- or 30-year career. Our focus is keeping costs low, using institutional-level pricing where available, and making sure the plan is getting value for every dollar it spends.

2. Simple, Disciplined Investment Strategy
Complexity is not a feature. We have seen too many plans built around expensive strategies that looked impressive in a presentation room but didn't deliver for the people depending on those pensions. Our approach focuses on broad diversification, consistent rebalancing, and a strategy that every board member can understand, explain, and stand behind. If you can't explain it at a board meeting, it probably doesn't belong in the plan.

3. Oversight and Accountability
Serving on a pension board carries real legal responsibility, and board members deserve an advisor who takes that seriously. We act as a genuine partner to the board, providing regular updates, clear documentation of every decision, and alignment with current best practices. When a decision needs to be made, the boards we work with know exactly why it's being made and what it means for the plan and the people it serves.

4. Transparent Reporting
A board shouldn't need a finance degree to understand what's happening in their plan. We provide straightforward reporting with full cost visibility and performance analysis that gives you a clear picture of where the plan has been, where it stands today, and how it compares to similar plans across the state. No jargon, no confusion, just a clear picture.

5. A Structure That Gets More Efficient Over Time
As plan assets grow, costs should come down, not stay flat or go up. Our approach is built so that efficiency improves as the plan grows. The structure that serves your department well at $10 million should serve it even better at $20 million.

Understanding Fees: Where Plans Go Wrong

Fees are one of the most important variables in pension plan health and one of the least understood. They tend to pile up in layers, some visible and many not. Investment management expenses, advisory fees, recordkeeping charges, and revenue sharing arrangements can all add up in ways that don't show up clearly on a single statement.

Here's a straightforward way to think about it. Consider a hypothetical plan with $30 million in assets. A reduction of just 20 basis points, two tenths of one percent, would put $60,000 back into the plan every year. A reduction of 40 basis points on that same plan means $120,000 annually staying invested for plan participants rather than going out the door in expenses. That's not a dramatic overhaul. That's a careful review of what the plan is paying and whether it's justified.

Every dollar saved in fees stays in the plan, working for the people who earned it.

Key Questions Every Pension Board Should Ask

Whether you are taking a fresh look at your current advisor or thinking about making a change, these questions get to the heart of how your plan is actually being managed.

Fees and Costs: What is the total all-in cost of the plan? How does it compare to similar municipal plans in West Virginia? What are all the administrative, investment management, and recordkeeping fees?

Investment Strategy: Is the portfolio more complex than it needs to be? How often is performance reviewed against benchmarks? When were the investments last reviewed and updated?

Board Responsibility: Who is accountable for plan decisions? Is your advisor legally obligated to act in the plan's best interest? How does your firm help the board address its legal obligations?

Service and Execution: Who is our dedicated point of contact? How quickly are requests and distributions handled? Does your advisor attend board meetings regularly or just show up once a year?

Transparency: Are the reports clear and easy to understand? Is the plan trending in the right direction relative to its history and peer plans? Can costs and performance be explained in plain language at a board meeting?


A Hypothetical Case Study: A West Virginia Police and Fire Pension Fund

The following reflects a situation we have encountered more than once while working with municipal pension plans across West Virginia. It is intended to illustrate common challenges and the approach we take to help boards address them.

The plan in this example had multiple providers with overlapping roles, limited visibility into total costs, and an investment structure that had grown more complicated than it needed to be. Fees were higher than they should have been, with certain funds carrying expense ratios well above what comparable options would charge. Benefit payments were going out steadily, and the gap between what was leaving the plan and what contributions and investment returns were bringing in had been quietly growing for some time.

What we found wasn't a failure of the board. They were engaged and doing their jobs. The challenge was the way the plan itself was set up. When costs are too high and the investment approach isn't working efficiently, even a hardworking board can find itself falling behind without a clear picture of why.

Our role was to stop that cycle. We helped simplify the investment strategy, reduce unnecessary costs, and align the plan with real-world cash flow: what's coming in, what's going out, and how the assets are working in between. By staying actively involved with the board and keeping communication consistent, we helped move the plan from reactive to proactive, building a structure focused on long-term stability and the employees it was built to protect.

The details of every plan are different. The approach is the same.

How We Stay Involved

Serving a pension plan well means staying involved between meetings, not just showing up once a year with a report. Here's what that looks like in practice.

We assist in preparing and reviewing your Investment Policy Statement, provide consistent performance reporting with full cost visibility, and benchmark your plan against similar municipal plans so the board always has an honest picture of where things stand. When fee structures need a closer look, we help identify what the plan is actually paying and whether it's worth it.

Beyond the numbers, we serve as a liaison between the board and your service providers, support the education of plan committee members, and stay in regular contact with trustees between formal reviews. JR attends pension board meetings regularly, so the board isn't just receiving information from someone who read the report that morning. They're working with someone who knows the plan's history, knows the people involved, and can explain what the data actually means in plain language.

For public safety departments in particular, including police and fire, we understand the unique funding structures, earlier retirement timelines, and survivor benefit considerations that come with managing these plans. That experience matters when the details get complicated.

Serving the People Who Protect
Our Communities

Want something you can bring to your next board meeting? Download our guide for a printable overview of our approach, including the key questions your board should be asking and a detailed case study from a West Virginia municipal plan.

Download our Pension Plan Guide

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if our municipal pension plan is paying too much in fees?

Most plans don't have a clear picture of their all-in costs because fees are spread across investment management, recordkeeping, advisory services, and sometimes revenue-sharing arrangements that don't show up clearly on a statement. A good starting point is requesting a full fee disclosure from your current provider and comparing it against what similar plans are paying. We offer a no-obligation review of your plan's cost structure so boards can see exactly what they're paying and whether it's justified.

What should a municipal pension board look for when evaluating a financial advisor?

The most important questions go beyond investment performance. Does the advisor show up to board meetings regularly? Are they legally obligated to act in the plan's best interest? Can they explain the cost structure clearly and compare it against peer plans? Do board members get reporting they can actually read and understand? A good advisor brings consistency, transparency, and genuine engagement to every meeting, not just the annual review.

Does Good Life Financial Advisors work with all types of municipal pension plans?

Yes. While JR has deep experience working with police and fire pension funds specifically, Good Life Financial Advisors of West Virginia works with municipal pension plans of all types across the state. The approach stays the same regardless of the plan: reduce unnecessary costs, simplify the investment structure, and make sure every board member understands exactly where things stand and why. If you'd like to talk through your specific situation, we're happy to start with a no-obligation review.

Contact Us
Let's Get Started

Are you ready to take the next step on the road to the Good Life? Feel free to call or email us to setup a complimentary Financial Future review to allow us identify how we can serve your needs.